As experts in IT and manufacturing software solutions at Open Source Integrators, we often guide our clients through the critical decision of choosing the right supply chain planning tool for their business. While Odoo’s DDMRP module made by the OCA is a powerful and integrated solution, not all manufacturing and distribution environments are created equal. The key to a successful implementation lies in aligning the software with the company’s existing processes, resources, and long-term strategic goals.
At Open Source Integrators, we want to help you by providing valuable information for your organization, through a clear framework for deciding when to take advantage of an advanced planning solution like Frepple and when to opt for the simplicity and integration of the OCA's DDMRP module.
When the OCA’s DDMRP is the right choice
OCA's DDMRP module is a modern, integrated solution that excels in environments where a planning system is not yet mature. It’s built directly into the Odoo ecosystem, which means seamless data flow and a unified user experience. This solution is best for companies that meet the following criteria:
- No established planning process: For companies just starting to mature their planning functions, OCA's DDMRP provides a clear, methodology-driven approach. It guides users through the core principles of Demand Driven Material Requirements Planning—from strategic positioning and buffer management to dynamic adjustments—without requiring a separate, complex system. This makes it an ideal first step toward a more data-driven supply chain.
- No dedicated planning resource: OCA's DDMRP is designed for efficiency. Its visual replenishment signals (red, yellow, green zones) and automated order recommendations reduce the need for a full-time, dedicated planner. The system’s intuitive interface allows a general supply chain manager or even a warehouse supervisor to manage inventory and production priorities effectively, freeing up valuable human capital.
- Simplicity and cost-effectiveness: Implementing OCA's DDMRP is a straightforward process. There is no need for a separate integration project, additional hosting, or licensing fees beyond the standard Odoo subscription. This makes it a highly cost-effective and low-risk option for small to medium-sized businesses looking to improve their supply chain without a significant investment in a new IT system.
When Frepple is the preferred option
Frepple is an open-source, advanced planning and scheduling (APS) solution that integrates seamlessly with Odoo. While it requires a separate implementation, its depth of features makes it the superior choice for companies with complex planning needs and a dedicated team of experts.
- Existing planning process and dedicated planners: If a company already has a planning team that uses tools like spreadsheets or is accustomed to detailed, data-intensive planning, Frepple offers a powerful upgrade. It provides advanced forecasting, scenario modeling ("what-if" analysis), and finite-capacity scheduling that goes far beyond what Odoo's native module offers. Planners can use Frepple to optimize production around constraints like machine availability, labor hours, and specific toolsets, a level of detail crucial for high-complexity manufacturing.
- Complex supply chain dynamics: Frepple is designed to handle more intricate supply chain scenarios. This includes companies that need:
- Advanced forecasting: Frepple’s engine uses multiple statistical models (e.g., Holt-Winters, Croston) to generate more accurate demand forecasts. It also has features to automatically detect and correct outliers, providing a more reliable foundation for planning.
- Detailed production scheduling: Frepple can generate both unconstrained (infinite-capacity) and fully constrained plans, ensuring that production schedules are realistic and achievable. Its visual Gantt chart allows planners to easily identify bottlenecks and manually adjust the schedule with a drag-and-drop interface.
- Multi-site and distribution planning: For companies with multiple warehouses or distribution centers, Frepple can generate a distribution plan and handle inventory rebalancing to optimize stock levels across the network.
- Open-Source flexibility: As a fellow open-source solution, Frepple’s core is fully customizable. For clients with highly unique business logic, Frepple's API and Python-based framework allow our team to build bespoke solutions or connect to other systems (e.g., MES, IoT devices) to create a truly tailored supply chain platform.
Conclusion
The decision between OCA's DDMRP and Frepple is not about one being "better" than the other, but rather which solution is a better fit for your specific needs.
- For companies seeking simplicity, a unified user experience, and a cost-effective way to get started with planning and scheduling, OCA’s DDMRP module is the ideal choice. It provides the foundational tools to mature your planning processes and requires minimal external resources.
- For companies with an established planning process, a dedicated planning team, and complex supply chain requirements, Frepple is the superior solution. Its advanced features for forecasting, scenario modeling, and finite-capacity scheduling provide the depth and flexibility needed to drive significant operational improvements.
Evaluating using Odoo for your manufacturing business?
Request a demo
At Open Source Integrators, we have a team of experts to help you analyze these factors and select the solution that will enable your team to work smarter, more efficiently, and more profitably.
